The PSA FedEx heist, by the numbers. Map of the Santa Ana area with the theft site marked.

The PSA FedEx heist, by the numbers

On October 13, 2026, PSA customer orders were stolen from a FedEx truck after pickup at PSA’s Santa Ana, California, facility. Here’s what the public record says, in numbers, and what it doesn’t.

The day

1 truck. A FedEx vehicle carrying graded orders back to their owners.

0 kilometres from PSA. Police say the truck was parked in an open lot at PSA’s facility in the 1600 block of East St. Andrew Place. The lot is private property but open to the public and not gated, though the business has security guards.2 PSA’s parent company, Collectors, leases the campus at 1600 and 1610 E. St. Andrew Place. Police have also said they haven’t established whether the truck was entered in that lot or somewhere along its route.

The reported area of the lot at PSA's facility, 1610 E. St. Andrew Place. The circle marks the area, not an exact spot. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
The reported area of the lot at PSA’s facility, 1610 E. St. Andrew Place. The circle marks the area, not an exact spot. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
The same block in aerial view. The circle marks the reported area of the lot, not an exact spot. Imagery: USGS The National Map / USDA NAIP (public domain).
The same block in aerial view. The circle marks the reported area of the lot, not an exact spot. Imagery: USGS The National Map / USDA NAIP (public domain).

60 to 90 minutes. Early reports, citing police, said the driver was away from the truck for 60 to 90 minutes. Police later told FreightWaves they couldn’t confirm that timeline, and how long the driver was gone is still part of the investigation.

Evening, per one TV report (NBC LA). An NBC LA reporter said the theft happened “last Tuesday evening,” and that Santa Ana police said the driver reported it “while he was doing a pickup at PSA cards.” Exact times — when the truck arrived, when it was left and when the theft was found — still haven’t been reported.1

Timeline of the October 13, 2026 PSA FedEx theft in Santa Ana.

1 missing lock. The driver found the lock on the rear cargo door gone and the contents disturbed.

What kind of truck? Police couldn’t confirm whether it was a tractor-trailer, a box truck or a smaller delivery vehicle. Was it a scheduled break? No report says so. Reports say only that the driver left the vehicle. Why a loaded truck was left unattended at the pickup site, and for how long, is one of the open questions in this case.

The load

2 full pallets taken, plus part of a third. Police say two pallets were taken whole and boxes were removed from a third.

About 250 packages. About 100 packages on each full pallet, plus about 50 from the third. How the pallets were moved off the truck, and how many FedEx pickups PSA’s Santa Ana site gets each day, hasn’t been reported.3

6,451 items on PSA’s public list, each with a PSA cert number, all deactivated. PSA has since found more stolen parcels; see the update below.4

About 3,900 different cards on that list. Plenty were in multiples: 51 copies of the 1990 Hoops #65 Michael Jordan alone.

About 133,000 cards a business day. That’s our estimate of PSA’s average pace in October 2026, from GemRate’s count of 2.79 million PSA-graded cards over 21 business days. At that pace, the 6,451 slabs on the list are about 5% of one day’s output.5 Whether this load was unusually big or valuable hasn’t been reported. PSA ships with UPS, FedEx and armoured carriers.

Public before it shipped? PSA’s own FAQ says grades are revealed in the customer’s account once payment is received, before final QA checks and shipping. PSA also scans every slab and posts front and back images to its public Cert Verification page. PSA doesn’t publish exactly when a new cert goes live in that lookup, so card details for a finished order can be online before the box leaves. No report says that played any part in this theft.

About 275 to 375 kg (roughly 600 to 825 lb). That’s our estimate of the slabs alone, card included, at 43 to 58 g per PSA slab. It doesn’t count boxes or pallets.

What was in the boxes

What was stolen. Per PSA’s official list, there were no comics, magazines, tickets or memorabilia. Words like “comic” and “jersey” appear only in card names. Eleven entries are graded sealed 1963–1976 Topps baseball wax packs. Fourteen entries have no card description (mostly “no grade voucher”) and can’t be identified.6 Police said the pallets contained “various trading cards, including, but not limited to, sports cards and Pokémon cards.”

From our count of that 6,451-item list, by category:9

Category Count Share
Pokémon 2,978 46.2%
One Piece 898 13.9%
Basketball 873 13.5%
Baseball 635 9.8%
Football 432 6.7%
Other TCGs 305 4.7%
Wrestling 89 1.4%
Non-sport / entertainment 87 1.3%
Other sports 64 1.0%
Soccer 42 0.7%
Hockey 23 0.4%
Graded sealed wax packs 11 0.2%
No description (unidentified) 14 0.2%
Total 6,451 100%

Other TCGs: Riftbound 61, Yu-Gi-Oh! 58, Dragon Ball 56, Naruto 45, Disney Lorcana 27, Gundam 26, Digimon 16, Magic: The Gathering 8, plus Union Arena, Jurassic Park, Weiss Schwarz and Detective Conan. Other sports: tennis 40, Formula 1 8, golf 6, drag racing 5, and a handful of UFC, boxing, bowling and mixed-sport cards. Non-sport and entertainment includes Disney, DC, Marvel, Star Wars, SpongeBob, and 20 vintage Charlie Chaplin film-star cards, among others.

Also from that count:

  • 2,978 Pokémon slabs (46%), including 29 Gold Stars and 273 Charizards
  • 898 One Piece, 89 wrestling, 58 Yu-Gi-Oh!, 56 Dragon Ball and 8 Magic: The Gathering
  • 1,831 Japanese-language cards (28%)
  • Top names: Victor Wembanyama 202, Michael Jordan 185, Cooper Flagg 96, Shohei Ohtani 89, LeBron James 61
  • Hockey: 23 slabs, including Cale Makar, the Hughes brothers, Connor McDavid, Macklin Celebrini and Connor Bedard
  • 20 cards marked 1/1 in their official descriptions; other serialized cards are counted below

Sports cards

The table above already shows each sport as a share of all 6,451 items. Counting only sports cards — basketball, baseball, football, hockey, soccer and other sports, and not wrestling, trading-card games, entertainment, wax packs or the 14 unidentified rows — there are 2,069 sports cards (32.1% of the list).

Sport Count Share of 6,451 Share of 2,069
Basketball 873 13.5% 42.2%
Baseball 635 9.8% 30.7%
Football 432 6.7% 20.9%
Other sports 64 1.0% 3.1%
Soccer 42 0.7% 2.0%
Hockey 23 0.4% 1.1%
Total 2,069 32.1% 100%

By year

The year is the first year in each official description: the start of a range such as 1994-95 or 2025-2026, or the only year listed.

The stolen items are overwhelmingly new cards. 4,669 (72.4%) are from 2020 or later, including 1,759 from 2025 (27.3%) and 1,238 from 2026 (19.2%). Next are 2024 (603, 9.3%) and 2023 (474, 7.3%). There are 76 different dated years. The earliest dated year is 1923. One more card is labelled only “1920s,” with no single year, and 14 undescribed voucher rows have no year at all.7

Decade Count Share
1920s 11 0.2%
1930s 8 0.1%
1940s 7 0.1%
1950s 74 1.1%
1960s 67 1.0%
1970s 35 0.5%
1980s 112 1.7%
1990s 442 6.9%
2000s 513 8.0%
2010s 499 7.7%
2020s 4,669 72.4%
No year 14 0.2%
Total 6,451 100%

The 1920s total is 10 cards dated 1923–1927 plus the one labelled only “1920s.” Shares are rounded to one decimal. The full count by individual year is in the appendix.

Serialized cards

PSA’s official list rarely shows a serial number. 20 descriptions are marked 1/1, and seven more say “serialized” without a number. Two other descriptions include “50/50,” but that’s a set name (2024 Topps 50/50), not a print run. Everything else on the list omits the serial.8

A public owner sheet of 382 serialized certs is the source of the counts below. All 6,451 official certs were checked against that sheet. 371 of those sheet certs appear on the official list (5.8% of 6,451). The other 11 sheet certs are not on PSA’s official list. How many of the remaining official-list items are serialized isn’t known, because those serials were never published.8

Of the 371 official-list items with a sheet serial:

Print run Count Share of 371 Share of 6,451
1/1 19 5.1% 0.3%
/2–/10 120 32.3% 1.9%
/11–/25 59 15.9% 0.9%
/26–/50 48 12.9% 0.7%
/51–/99 47 12.7% 0.7%
/100–/250 44 11.9% 0.7%
/251 or higher 28 7.5% 0.4%
Serial, print run not listed 6 1.6% 0.1%
Total 371 100% 5.8%

The sheet has 19 of the 20 official-list 1/1s; one official-list 1/1 isn’t on the sheet.

The public Sprunger registry added 368 of these 371 as serialized heist entries. The other three were already on the registry as part of the first six published cards, so they weren’t added again.

Grades

PSA’s official list has no grades, and the stolen certs are deactivated, so the 6,451 items can’t be split by grade. Grades are known only for the 371 official-list cards that appear on the serialized owner sheet. That is 5.8% of the list, not a grade distribution of the heist.10

Grade Count Share of 371
PSA 10 129 34.8%
PSA 9 136 36.7%
PSA 8 57 15.4%
PSA 7 or lower 18 4.9%
Grade 0 (authentic or ungraded) 31 8.4%
Total 371 100%

The full 382-row sheet, including 11 certs not on the official list, is PSA 10: 133; PSA 9: 142; PSA 8: 57; PSA 7 or lower: 18; and Grade 0: 32. The “PSA 7 or lower” group is eight PSA 7s, seven PSA 6s, and three listed only as “Grade 1–5.”

Rookies

86 items (1.3%) are marked “RC,” “Rookie” or “RPA” in PSA’s official descriptions. The rest of the list, 6,365 items (98.7%), has no such wording. This is a minimum, not a true rookie/non-rookie split: PSA often leaves that label off.12

How many customers?

About 120 to 140 customer orders, by our estimate. PSA has not published a customer count. Grouping the 6,451 official certs into runs no more than 1,000 numbers apart gives 140 blocks. 94 of those blocks have 20 or more cards, and they hold 6,295 items (98%). The median block is 43 cards. Because PSA assigns certs in sequence when an order reaches Research & ID, one contiguous block is usually one submission. The range is 120–140 because a large order can split across blocks and a few blocks may hold two small orders. Some packages were dealer submissions for several collectors.13

How long were they at PSA?

Submission dates are not on PSA’s list and have not been reported. What can be estimated is when each cert was assigned, which happens at Research & ID, not at grading or shipping.14

Estimated cert window Items
Before November 2025 117
December 2025 – March 2026 503
April 2026 540
May 2026 931
June 2026 1,843
July 2026 1,524
August 2026 830
September 2026 105
October 1–13, 2026 58
Total 6,451

5,668 items (88%) fall in the April–August 2026 windows. For those orders, that is about two to six months between Research & ID and the October 13 return shipment, which fits economy and value service levels. The latest certs, from early October, came through in days or weeks. Because the benchmark can be off by about ±1 million certs (roughly ±2 weeks), some items near a month’s edge could move, but the large majority still sits in that two-to-six-month range. This is not a record of when the cards were submitted.14

The money

$963,000. PSA’s estimate for the two full pallets, as reported by police. Police say the final total will be higher.11

$3.2 million to $27 million. A public tracker’s range for every copy on the list, valued from PSA 8 up to PSA 10. Most grades on the official list aren’t public, so the real figure sits somewhere in that range. The tracker publishes per-card estimates at those grades, not sold prices for these copies, so an average or median of actual card values can’t be computed from the public data.11

About $1.38 million. The tracker’s PSA 10 value for the top card, a 1999 Pokémon Base Set 1st Edition Charizard. Its PSA 8 value is about $41,000, and this copy’s grade isn’t public.11

Grading fees: 100% refunded. PSA pays fair market value up to each item’s declared insured value, and owners can take back any card that’s recovered.

What’s still not known

Customer count: PSA hasn’t published one. Our estimate from the cert-number blocks, above, is about 120 to 140 customer orders.13 About 250 packages went missing, and some were dealer submissions for several collectors. Arrests and recoveries: none reported. Cracked slabs: no report says any were found. One hobby news site notes that once a slab is cracked, the raw card can’t be tied to the theft. Where any plastic went: no report says. The map shows Orange County’s three county landfills and six transfer stations within about 45 minutes of PSA, only as nearby options. Its dashed freeway routes are possible routes out of the area, not reported ones.

Where Sprunger comes in. A cracked slab doesn’t always mean a lost trail. Every card carries small details most people never notice: tiny print flaws, centring, corner and edge wear, surface marks. If a clear photo of the card exists from before it went missing, our process compares those details to find the same card raw, even with no label. That’s also why a documented card is worth more to begin with: buyers know exactly which card they’re getting. Have photos of a stolen card? Add it to the Lost & Stolen Registry.

Reported theft site, possible freeway routes and nearby Orange County landfills and transfer stations. Dashed routes are possible, not reported. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Reported theft site, possible freeway routes and nearby Orange County landfills and transfer stations. Dashed routes are possible, not reported. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

The investigation

Santa Ana police and the FBI are investigating, according to PSA. As of November 20, the FBI’s website had no press release, seeking-information poster or reward for this case. The public tip line is the one PSA published: the FBI Los Angeles office at 310-477-6565 (press 1 and ask for the duty agent on the PSA theft).

The FBI’s general cargo-theft guidance is useful context, not a finding about this case. It says straight cargo theft “often occurs at truck stops, parking lots… and other situations where cargo is left unattended,” and it lists “high security rear door locks” among its precautions. In June 2026, the FBI’s Philadelphia office put 2025 cargo-theft losses in the United States and Canada at nearly $725 million, up 60%.

Sprunger’s analysis: theories, not facts

These are our theories from public reporting. They aren’t findings, and they don’t point at any person or company.

Theory 1: the target was the load, not one card. Whole pallets of sealed, look-alike boxes were taken. Nothing has been reported to show anyone knew which box held which card. Would confirm: evidence that specific parcels were picked out. Would rule it out: the opposite.

Theory 2: an opportunity, with planning on the logistics. The lot was open and ungated, and a PSA label can itself signal valuable contents. Card details for finished orders can be public before shipping, though nothing ties that to this case. Moving two full pallets suggests a vehicle and enough time. Would settle it: the time window and the surveillance footage police are reviewing.

Open question: why this truck? PSA ships with several carriers. Nothing public says how often FedEx picks up there, whether this load was larger or more valuable than usual, or whether its timing or route set it apart. Until police release more, “why this one” stays open. Chance, timing or something about the load are all still possible.

Theory 3: built for resale, not a collection. Thousands of mostly modern cards, many sold in multiples, suit resale far more than one person’s binder. Graded copies with dead certs are easy to catch, so this theory says the cards could be held for a while or cracked and sold raw. On the other side, no confirmed listing has surfaced. The one early “match” turned out to be a victim’s own pre-listed cards.

Theory 4: the 1/1s are the clue. A serialized card or a 1/1 is close to unsellable, even raw, because its number identifies it. Those cards may be held, dumped or stripped of their slabs. That makes a serialized card surfacing, or a pile of discarded PSA slab plastic and labels, a lead worth reporting.

If you see either, don’t buy and don’t confront anyone. Note the cert, serial and listing, then contact the FBI Los Angeles office at 310-477-6565 (press 1 and ask for the duty agent on the PSA theft).

Where Sprunger fits

The Sprunger Lost & Stolen registry lists hundreds of the heist’s serialized cards as text-only entries, so a buyer can check a serial number before paying.

Your own cards don’t have to go missing to be worth documenting. A Lost & Stolen Registry Record documents a trading card you still have. A documented card gives buyers confidence and can be worth more even if it’s never stolen. And if it ever is, the record is already there.

Update: PSA finds more stolen parcels

Unknown. That’s how many more parcels PSA has now tied to the theft. On November 10, PSA added an editor’s note to its October 23 update: “During our ongoing investigation and audit of shipment records, we identified additional parcels impacted by the October 13 theft.” It says it found them “by reconciling shipment manifests and outbound logs.”

6,451 still on the public list. As of November 11, PSA’s published list hadn’t changed. So these parcels are additional losses, not recoveries, and their cert numbers aren’t public yet. PSA says it “will share additional certificate numbers as the investigation allows.”

Certs deactivated, owners covered. PSA says the items were insured, it has deactivated their certificates, and it’s contacting owners directly. Compensation follows the same fair market value terms, up to each item’s declared insured value.

What the note doesn’t say: how many parcels or slabs, which cards, or why they weren’t counted at first. It doesn’t mention the truck, the driver or the lot.

What it means for buyers: a slab can be stolen and still not be on the list. Check every PSA cert in PSA’s own lookup before you pay. A deactivated cert is a stop sign. If you think a card came off that truck, contact the FBI Los Angeles office at 310-477-6565 (press 1 and ask for the duty agent on the PSA theft).

Appendix: the 6,451 items by year

The year is the first year in each official description, the same method as the decade table. Shares under 0.05% are shown as <0.1%; other shares are rounded to one decimal.

Year Count Share Year Count Share Year Count Share
1923 2 <0.1% 1973 5 0.1% 2003 91 1.4%
1926 7 0.1% 1975 2 <0.1% 2004 56 0.9%
1927 1 <0.1% 1976 1 <0.1% 2005 63 1.0%
1930 2 <0.1% 1980 6 0.1% 2006 24 0.4%
1933 2 <0.1% 1981 1 <0.1% 2007 35 0.5%
1934 3 <0.1% 1982 2 <0.1% 2008 23 0.4%
1935 1 <0.1% 1983 3 <0.1% 2009 36 0.6%
1940 3 <0.1% 1984 4 0.1% 2010 68 1.1%
1948 2 <0.1% 1985 6 0.1% 2011 31 0.5%
1949 2 <0.1% 1986 11 0.2% 2012 12 0.2%
1950 1 <0.1% 1987 12 0.2% 2013 7 0.1%
1951 1 <0.1% 1988 19 0.3% 2014 23 0.4%
1952 7 0.1% 1989 48 0.7% 2015 49 0.8%
1953 60 0.9% 1990 55 0.9% 2016 58 0.9%
1954 3 <0.1% 1991 23 0.4% 2017 32 0.5%
1955 1 <0.1% 1992 17 0.3% 2018 72 1.1%
1956 1 <0.1% 1993 18 0.3% 2019 147 2.3%
1960 9 0.1% 1994 11 0.2% 2020 67 1.0%
1961 5 0.1% 1995 35 0.5% 2021 306 4.7%
1962 43 0.7% 1996 65 1.0% 2022 222 3.4%
1963 1 <0.1% 1997 36 0.6% 2023 474 7.3%
1965 8 0.1% 1998 98 1.5% 2024 603 9.3%
1969 1 <0.1% 1999 84 1.3% 2025 1,759 27.3%
1970 1 <0.1% 2000 90 1.4% 2026 1,238 19.2%
1971 21 0.3% 2001 39 0.6% 1920s* 1 <0.1%
1972 5 0.1% 2002 56 0.9% No year 14 0.2%

Total: 6,451 (100%). *One card is labelled only “1920s,” with no single year. Shares under 0.05% are shown as <0.1%.

Notes

These notes flag information that could not be confirmed or is incomplete.

  1. Only one TV report, NBC LA, places the theft in the evening. Exact times — when the truck arrived, when it was left and when the theft was found — have not been reported. An earlier public timeline still said no time of day was given. ↩

  2. Police describe “an open lot at PSA’s facility” that is private but open to the public and not gated, with security guards present. Which part of the campus lot, and who manages lot security day to day, has not been reported. Police have also said they have not established whether the truck was entered in that lot or along its route. ↩

  3. The “about 250 packages” figure comes from police via reporting (about 100 on each full pallet and about 50 from the third). How the pallets were moved off the truck, and how many FedEx pickups PSA’s Santa Ana site gets each day, has not been made public. ↩

  4. On November 10, PSA said it had identified additional parcels from the same theft. It has not published how many, which cards, or their cert numbers. ↩

  5. The “about 133,000 cards a business day” figure is our estimate from GemRate’s October 2026 count (2.79 million PSA-graded cards over 21 business days). Not every graded card ships that month, some go to the PSA Vault, and some grading may happen at other PSA sites. ↩

  6. Fourteen rows on PSA’s official list have no card description (voucher or “no spec info” wording). A count of 15 included the list’s header row; there is no 15th blank data row. ↩

  7. After reading year-range formats such as 1994-95 and 2025-2026, a year could be taken from every description except those 14 undescribed voucher rows. A first pass had left 47 rows unparsed; the other 33 were those range and decade formats, not missing years. ↩

  8. PSA’s official list almost never includes a serial number in the description. The serialization figures come from matching the list to a public owner sheet of 382 serialized certs, not from a lookup of all 6,451 certs. All 6,451 official certs were checked against that sheet. How many of the remaining official-list items are serialized is unknown, because those serials were not published. ↩↩

  9. Every one of the 6,451 rows was assigned a category, with leftover rows hand-checked to zero. A few judgments are noted in the methods — for example, mixed-sport brands classified by the subject, and nine One Piece basketball promos kept in One Piece. ↩

  10. PSA’s official 6,451-item list has no grades, and the stolen certs are deactivated, so a grade distribution of the full list is not possible. The grades in this article cover only the cards on the public serialized owner sheet that also appear on the official list (371 of 6,451). ↩

  11. $963,000 is PSA’s estimate for the two full pallets, as reported by police, who say the final total will be higher. The $3.2 million–$27 million range is a third-party tracker’s estimate for every copy on the list, valued from PSA 8 to PSA 10, because most grades are not public. The tracker publishes per-card estimates at those grades, not sold prices for these copies, so an average or median of actual card values cannot be computed from the public data. The November 10 parcels are not in either figure. ↩↩↩

  12. “Rookie” here means the official description includes “RC,” “Rookie” or “RPA.” PSA often leaves that wording off, so 86 is a minimum, not a true rookie/non-rookie split. ↩

  13. PSA has not published how many customers were affected. About 120–140 is our estimate from the cert-number blocks, not an official count. A large order can split across blocks, and a few blocks may hold two small orders. Some packages were dealer submissions for several collectors. ↩↩

  14. These are estimated windows for when certs were assigned at Research & ID, not submission dates, grading dates or ship dates. Submission dates are not on PSA’s list or in public reporting. The month windows use a community cert-to-month table (Elite Fourum, 24 August 2026, built from GemRate monthly volumes). One reply to that table said it runs about 1 million certs high; treat the windows as ±1 million certs, or roughly ±2 weeks. The September and early October windows are extrapolated at about 2.3 million certs a month. Confidence is medium for 2025–26 certs and low for older outlier certs. ↩↩

Sources

Public reporting and official pages used for this article:

Category, year, serialization, grade, rookie and cert-block counts in this article were calculated from PSA’s official 6,451-item list and, where noted, from a public serialized owner sheet. Those methods are described in the notes above.

Questions: originals@sprunger.shop. Follow Sprunger Originals on X and Facebook.

Sprunger Originals, Newmarket, Ontario

Back to blog

Stay connected

Follow Sprunger Originals for new arrivals, Sprunger Scores and Lost & Stolen alerts.