The Snapshot
A cert number that comes back on PSA's site is where checking starts, not the proof. Custom PSA-style labels, some printed with real cert numbers, have been offered on AliExpress, and more than 6,451 items stolen in the October 13 FedEx theft have had their certs deactivated. Compare the card in the slab with PSA's own images, check it against our Lost & Stolen registry, and give your cards a Trading Card Digital Twin whose Web3 COA is tied to the card itself, not just the label.
After the October 13 theft from a FedEx truck in Santa Ana, California, a lot of collectors were told the same thing: check the cert. That is still the right first step. It is no longer enough on its own.
A matching number only tells you that the number exists in PSA's database. It does not, by itself, prove that the slab in front of you is the card PSA graded, or that the card has not been reported stolen.
Custom labels, real cert numbers
On November 10, Cardboard Journal reported that AliExpress sellers are offering custom PSA-style labels, some of them printed with real certification numbers. A listing shared by collectibles commentator Max Long on November 9 was priced at about US$4.05 and showed more than 5,000 sales. The labels were sold as customizable labels, not as graded cards: front and back designs, barcodes, QR codes and a holographic patch.
Roman Pioneer, founder of the authentication database CheckCOA, found other stores selling labels together with empty cases. Buyer photos showed labels carrying real, active PSA cert numbers. Looking those numbers up returns a genuine card and grade. Dexerto reported the same pattern, including one copied label that used an active cert number for a GEM MT 10 card.
There is a second risk as well. A Japanese listing sold genuine PSA, BGS and ARS labels taken out of their cases. CheckCOA marked those as suspect, not confirmed fakes. A real label can still end up in a new case with a different card.
PSA says this itself. On its cert verification page, the company warns that looking up a certification number does not eliminate risk, because criminals can copy real numbers from public records. It tells buyers to compare the card with PSA's own images, check the case for tampering and buy from trusted sellers.
The October 13 theft makes the same point
On October 13, 2026, PSA customer parcels were stolen from a FedEx truck after pickup at PSA's Santa Ana facility. PSA later published a list of 6,451 stolen items and deactivated those certs. On November 12, Collectibles News reported that PSA had identified additional parcels while it continued auditing shipment records. The company has not said how many more items that adds, so the total is now higher than 6,451 but not yet known. PSA says it has deactivated the new certs as well, but it has not yet published a supplemental list.
A deactivated cert should not come back as a live record. An active match, though, only tells you that number is still in the database. After this theft, and with copied labels in circulation, you still have to check that the card in the holder is the card PSA photographed, and that it is not on a stolen list.
Before you buy, run the cert, and the card itself when you can, through the Sprunger Originals Lost & Stolen Card Program. If you are offered a card that appears on the registry, do not confront the seller. Email us at originals@sprunger.shop instead, and we will work through the police.
How to check a PSA slab
Use this as a practical sequence, not a single pass/fail test. One mismatch is enough to stop.
- Look up the cert on PSA. Enter the number on PSA Cert Verification. If the cert is deactivated or does not return a record, stop.
- Compare PSA's official images with the card in the slab, and with the seller's photos. Look at centering and borders, corners and edges, surface marks and print dots. You are checking that it is the same copy of the card, not only the same player and year.
- Compare the seller's photos with PSA's photos carefully. If the listing uses the same crop as PSA's cert page, or the card in the listing does not match those images, walk away. Ask for clear, current photos of the front, back, label, slab edges and the label tilted in the light.
- Check the label generation and dates. The style of the label should fit the cert. PSA updated its labels in 2017 with a Lighthouse hologram, fugitive ink and a QR code on the back. An older-style label on a recently issued cert, or a new-style label on a cert from well before that change, is a reason to pause. Check any issue or last-update dates on the cert page against what the seller is claiming.
- Look at typography and print quality. Compare letterforms, spacing, alignment and sharpness with a known genuine label of the same generation. Soft, uneven or obviously reset type is a warning sign. A close font is not proof either way.
- Tilt the hologram. On current labels, PSA says the Lighthouse effect should show an on/off illumination as the label is angled. Older labels use a different hologram, so compare against a genuine example from the same period. A silver patch that merely reflects light is not the same thing.
- Hold the label to a strong light. PSA's buyer's guide says you should be able to see through a genuine label enough to make out text on the other side. A label that is too thick or fully opaque may have an extra layer added.
- Inspect the slab back and the case. Look at the back of the label, the QR code on later labels, and the sonic weld around the edges. PSA describes "frosting" or cloudy plastic, hairline cracks, and a holder that flexes or starts to pop where the weld has been broken. Glue along the seam is a red flag.
- Match the cert to the card. The player, year, set, card number, grade and any qualifiers on the label must match both the card in the holder and the PSA record. A front and back that do not belong together is an immediate stop.
- Check the Lost & Stolen registry. Search the cert, and the card, on the registry. Dealers and collectors can also join the program and send photos of a card they have in hand for a check before they buy.
Red flags
- The cert looks up, but PSA's photos do not match the card in the slab.
- The listing photos appear to be copied from PSA's cert page.
- The label style or hologram does not fit the cert's issue period.
- The label will not show text through it under a strong light, or the case looks frosted, cracked, glued or unusually flexible at the weld.
- The price is well below the market, the seller is new or hard to verify, or they will not provide current photos of the edges, back and tilted label.
- The cert is deactivated, or the card appears on a stolen list, including our Lost & Stolen registry.
Why a digital twin with a Web3 COA matters
A copied label can carry a real cert number. A genuine label can be moved into a new case. In both situations, the number on the plastic is no longer a reliable link to the card. The proof has to live on the card itself: its surface and the marks that make that copy one of a kind.
That is what a Sprunger Originals Trading Card Digital Twin is built to do. When you order one, we keep a private record of full-resolution front and back photos and the marks that stay with the card: centering and borders, corner and edge wear, print dots and other print flaws, creases, surface marks and any miscut. Those details remain whether the card is raw, slabbed, cracked out or regraded.
A Web3 COA from Verisart records the card's identity and ownership, based on a photo review. It is not a grade, and it is not an in-hand authentication by PSA or any other grader. It includes the card's photos and is a transferable record for your collection, a sale, a gift or an insurance claim. You do not need to send us the card. If it is already in a slab, we record the grader and cert number from your slab photo as one detail among others, not as the whole proof.
The Verisart Web3 COA is time-stamped with OpenTimestamps and anchored in a Bitcoin block header, so anyone can confirm when the card was documented and that the record has not been changed since. That Bitcoin time-stamp belongs to the Verisart COA. If you only want registry protection, a Lost & Stolen Registry Record keeps a private photo record of the card at a lower price, but it is not a digital twin and does not include a Verisart COA or that transferable, time-stamped proof.
If someone later offers a card with a convincing cloned label, the label does not transfer the twin. A check compares the card's own surface and marks with the private record. When you buy a Web3 COA twin, an NFT twin or a Lost & Stolen Registry Record, the card is automatically added to the Lost & Stolen Card Program. It is not listed as lost or stolen unless you report it.
Pricing, in Canadian dollars: a Web3 COA twin is $16.99, an NFT twin is $19.99, and a Lost & Stolen Registry Record on its own is $9.99. Repeat Web3 COA twins are $11.99. You must have the card in your possession, and photo ID and proof of possession are required after checkout. You'll find the Digital Twin, and the rest of our card tools, in the Sprunger Card Management collection. If you have a 1979 O-Pee-Chee or Topps Wayne Gretzky rookie, there is a Gretzky rookie card digital twin as well.
A matching cert is where checking starts. Compare the card. Check the registry. Then give your own cards a record that a cloned label cannot pick up and walk away with.
Sources
- Sean, "AliExpress sellers offer custom PSA-style labels, some with real cert numbers," Cardboard Journal, November 10, 2026 (updated November 14, 2026).
- Zackerie Fairfax, "Pokemon collectors fear fake PSA slabs after AliExpress sells custom labels and cases for any card," Dexerto, November 10, 2026.
- Matt Johnson, "PSA Identifies Additional Parcels Stolen in October 13 FedEx Theft," Collectibles News, November 12, 2026.
- PSA, Cert Verification; PSA Security: A Buyer's Guide; PSA Labels Get New Look, New Technology.